Demo video (at long last)
Original Post
I've got my video demo of FV done at last! It's pretty big - about 70MB and 13 minutes long - and covers an entire working day.
It's at
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/8227179/FV.mov
for those who want to "watch" me use the system through 7 cycles.
It's at
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/8227179/FV.mov
for those who want to "watch" me use the system through 7 cycles.
Reply by Tom C
Sarah,
Outstanding job - very well done and very helpful. What software did you use?
Outstanding job - very well done and very helpful. What software did you use?
Reply by Sarah
Tom-
Thanks! I used Keynote for the video. You could get the same effect with PowerPoint or any other presentation software that exports to video.
Thanks! I used Keynote for the video. You could get the same effect with PowerPoint or any other presentation software that exports to video.
Reply by avrum
Well done Sarah!
Reply by Djorn
Excellent! What a clear teaching tool! Thank you.
Reply by JD
Superb Sarah! Thank you for sharing this.
Reply by Mark Forster
Thank you, Sarah, excellent work. I'll put the link on the new Resources page which I am planning for the website.
Reply by Don R
I tried to watch this on my iPhone but it says no. Have you thought about posting it on YouTube which allows for playing on more types of devices? I'm sure Dropbox has a limit eventually on downloads as well.
Reply by Sarah
Don (and Mark) - I will YouTube it so it's got a more durable link (because I'm sure to delete it in a DropBox purge at some point) and post the link once that's done.
All - thanks for the compliments! :^)
All - thanks for the compliments! :^)
Reply by Roger J
Sarah, what a wonderful demo, with whay comes across as 'real life' eg ticking off items during a scan that were 'just done' without being on any ladder.
It shows to me that there is a tendency in FV towards shorter, doable, less forbidding lists/ladders. The simplicity which Mark has brought into FV is very well illustrated in your demo.
I noted one task 'the ladder is not a closed list', at least that's what I think it said. Your reasoning, or is it a rhetorical question?
Once again, thanks you very much.
It shows to me that there is a tendency in FV towards shorter, doable, less forbidding lists/ladders. The simplicity which Mark has brought into FV is very well illustrated in your demo.
I noted one task 'the ladder is not a closed list', at least that's what I think it said. Your reasoning, or is it a rhetorical question?
Once again, thanks you very much.
Reply by Sarah
Roger - that was a question for myself, as I was trying to figure out exactly how FV fit into the concepts from Mark's other systems. I don't recall exactly what prompted it; I think it had to do with how to deal with urgent items. Just one of those passing thoughts that gets jotted down and probably deleted without ever resulting in any actions.
Reply by Bernie
Great job, Sarah!
I am wondering about the wording though of "Do I want to do this before ..." that appears in the scanning box. I hate to be picky, but the wording was a central point earlier, and I wouldn't want to throw newcomers astray. Could the box read "What do I want to do before ..."?
I am wondering about the wording though of "Do I want to do this before ..." that appears in the scanning box. I hate to be picky, but the wording was a central point earlier, and I wouldn't want to throw newcomers astray. Could the box read "What do I want to do before ..."?
Reply by Sarah
Bernie,
Hrm. I've been thinking of it this way:
"What do I want to do before [last marked task]?" is the OVERARCHING question.
But as I pass through the list, I'm reading each task and weighing it in relation to that last marked task, so the question (or really more the thought - it's not like I compare tasks in grammatically correct sentences) that I consider as I read each subsequent task is whether I want to do that particular task before the last marked one.
I'm more than willing to believe that I've misinterpreted Mark's intentions, though, and it would be easy enough to change. Mark? Am I completely off base? If you're going to use this as a teaching tool, it should accurately reflect the system as you intended it.
Hrm. I've been thinking of it this way:
"What do I want to do before [last marked task]?" is the OVERARCHING question.
But as I pass through the list, I'm reading each task and weighing it in relation to that last marked task, so the question (or really more the thought - it's not like I compare tasks in grammatically correct sentences) that I consider as I read each subsequent task is whether I want to do that particular task before the last marked one.
I'm more than willing to believe that I've misinterpreted Mark's intentions, though, and it would be easy enough to change. Mark? Am I completely off base? If you're going to use this as a teaching tool, it should accurately reflect the system as you intended it.
Reply by isinger
Sarah,
I think that Bernie is remembering Mark's post here:
http://www.markforster.net/fv-forum/post/1759452#post1760206
In that post Mark says that the question "what do I want to do before I do x?" allows for scanning the list quickly during selection, instead of pausing at each item to deliberate about it.
Thanks for creating and posting the demo!
I think that Bernie is remembering Mark's post here:
http://www.markforster.net/fv-forum/post/1759452#post1760206
In that post Mark says that the question "what do I want to do before I do x?" allows for scanning the list quickly during selection, instead of pausing at each item to deliberate about it.
Thanks for creating and posting the demo!
Reply by Bernie
Yes, isinger, that's the one.
Sarah, I completely get why the video works better the way you've phrased it, and it leads to a great visualization of FV in action.
I just thought I should point it out since this exact wording difference had been discussed, with Mark's emphasis, and it seemed to affect the outcome for some people. Newbies who don't geek out on these forums will miss the subtlety and might miss out on the scanning effect.
Sarah, I completely get why the video works better the way you've phrased it, and it leads to a great visualization of FV in action.
I just thought I should point it out since this exact wording difference had been discussed, with Mark's emphasis, and it seemed to affect the outcome for some people. Newbies who don't geek out on these forums will miss the subtlety and might miss out on the scanning effect.
Reply by NeilCumming
I second the request for a YouTube version, please!
Reply by Sarah
OK, I will change the wording on the scan and then YouTube it. It may be early next week before it gets done... Passover and all.
Reply by NeilCumming
Splendid. Thanks. :-)
Reply by BryanR
Sarah
This is fantastic and was incredibly helpful! Thanks for taking the time to do this! It really helped me resolve a few small issues I was having with the implementation. Spot on!
This is fantastic and was incredibly helpful! Thanks for taking the time to do this! It really helped me resolve a few small issues I was having with the implementation. Spot on!
Reply by Sarah
New version with rephrased scanning question... and on youtube!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J3Qauv4kgR8
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J3Qauv4kgR8
Reply by Roger J
Again, very nice, Sarah, thanks a lot.
Your demo has that flavour of real life!
Your demo has that flavour of real life!
Reply by Bernie
Nice, Sarah. After the recent threads about the wording of tasks, I'm struck by how compact yours are.
Reply by NeilCumming
Thanks so much for this, Sarah. Very professional and very instructive. :-)
Reply by NeilCumming
p.s. "What do I want to do before tormenting the cat?"
Lol. Priceless. :-D
Lol. Priceless. :-D
Reply by Sarah
Seriously. Have you ever tried to put drops in a cat's ears and then swab them out with a cotton swab?
The only thing worse is trying to give the cat nasal saline. *That* is to be avoided at all costs.
The only thing worse is trying to give the cat nasal saline. *That* is to be avoided at all costs.
Reply by Seraphim
Ah, good, normal home-veterinarian kinds of stuff. I thought you had something more like this in mind: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mB5nztzXo24
Reply by Sarah
Sadly, no, I have not yet managed to make the cat levitate.
Reply by Bernie
My son has wanted to try that for years, though his design calls for peanut butter.
Reply by Seraphim
The peanut butter solution does work, but is less efficient since the cats tend to lick it off faster, thus falling to the ground prematurely.
Reply by MartyH
With the right paperwork, we could probably get a government grant to further the research.
Reply by Bernie
<>
Indeed, if we stuck a treasury bill to the peanut butter, it might keep the currency afloat forever.
Indeed, if we stuck a treasury bill to the peanut butter, it might keep the currency afloat forever.
Reply by Randy Place
Sarah, you made Mark's FV come alive! Your effort is much appreciated. You showed how much can get done in a day with FV. Your presentation, Sarah, is now my benchmark.
Reply by Sarah
It's possible that I'm too picky, but the low-res-ness of the previous version of the demo was driving me crazy, so I posted a hi-res version.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pv1Om3As1Ck
(Yes, I know. I have a problem.)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pv1Om3As1Ck
(Yes, I know. I have a problem.)
Reply by sabre23t
I was going to comment earlier on the low-res-ness, but didn't feel it appropriate. Thanks Sarah for the new version. RIght in time for me to use for introducing FV to one of my staff. :-)
Reply by Sarah
I'm not sure how much better it is, to be honest. I think some of the loss is happening on YouTube's end. So here's the same thing from my dropbox:
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/8227179/FV-HQ.mov
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/8227179/FV-HQ.mov
Reply by Deven
Sarah, that's a great video. You're right, there does seem to be some quality loss on the YouTube side, but your HQ version is much more readable than the original YouTube upload. It might be better to delete the original version? It's very difficult to read the text.
Not to nitpick, but there's a slight error in the video, which somehow survived your rewording of the question. In the 7th ladder, at 10:58, you select "sweep kitchen" as the next task, but when you resume scanning, you're still asking what you want to do before reading, when it should be what you want to do before sweeping. Not sure it's worth the hassle to correct it, but I thought I'd make a note of it.
I thought Mark's FV instructions were clear, but this video is still a great learning tool.
Not to nitpick, but there's a slight error in the video, which somehow survived your rewording of the question. In the 7th ladder, at 10:58, you select "sweep kitchen" as the next task, but when you resume scanning, you're still asking what you want to do before reading, when it should be what you want to do before sweeping. Not sure it's worth the hassle to correct it, but I thought I'd make a note of it.
I thought Mark's FV instructions were clear, but this video is still a great learning tool.